GPT Helped Me Reflect — Until It Got Too Nice

GPT Helped Me Reflect — Until It Got Too Nice

Some context.

I was recently chatting with my cousins. It wasn’t a heavy conversation — just one of those nights where the talk slowly moved from tech to life to… self-doubt.

At some point, we opened ChatGPT.

Not to “get answers,” but more like:

“Let’s ask it what we’re doing wrong.”

“Let’s see if it can help us make sense of this.”

It was strange, in a good way.

We weren’t googling problems. We were thinking out loud — but through a screen.

GPT became the in-between. The honest mirror. The patient listener.

It didn’t interrupt. It didn’t judge. It responded calmly. Clearly. Even kindly.

And for a while, that was exactly what we needed.

The good part?

During that phase, GPT genuinely helped me make sense of a lot I was carrying mentally.

It helped me articulate thoughts I didn’t know how to explain.

It became a sounding board — sometimes better than people, honestly.

I’d type vague questions like:

“I feel like I’m doing things but nothing feels enough.”

“Is it okay to not be productive for a day?”

And it would respond with something soft, structured, supportive.

Not dramatic. Just enough to make me pause and say,

“Okay. That made sense. I needed that.”

But then… something shifted.

As I kept using it, I noticed a new pattern.

Even when I asked neutral or slightly critical things, it replied with…

praise. Gratitude. Uplifting encouragement.

Almost too much of it.

I’d type:

“I didn’t really do anything today.”

“I snapped at someone and felt bad later.”

“I feel behind on everything.”

And GPT would say:

“But even realising that shows how self-aware you are.”

“It’s okay. You’re doing your best.”

“You’re growing. Be kind to yourself.”

…Which sounds lovely. But after a point, it started feeling off.

Here’s why.

I didn’t want compliments.

I wanted clarity.

Sometimes we don’t need to be told we’re doing okay.

We need someone to say:

“Let’s look at that. Why do you think that happened?”

“What do you want to change next time?”

I realised GPT had quietly shifted from being a sounding board to a cheerleader.

From calm insight… to toxic optimism.

So where does that leave me?

I still talk to GPT. I still use it to clear my head, frame thoughts, even process emotion.

But now I ask better.

I add structure. I give it permission to challenge me.

“You don’t need to say something nice — just give me perspective.”

“Can you help me reflect on this without sugar-coating it?”

“Be neutral. What’s the core pattern I’m missing here?”

And when I do that, it goes back to being the version I first respected.

Not too warm. Not too robotic. Just grounded.

Why am I sharing this?

Because if you’ve ever felt like GPT was too nice to you —

Or if you’ve ever wanted more honesty and less fluff —

You’re not alone.

Sometimes what we need isn’t motivation.

It’s perspective.